"The Washington State ruling this month involves a case brought by Christian Appel, the father of a 12-year-old daughter. He and the girl's mother parted after she was born, and he and the baby lived with his parents in Germany.
In 1997 Mr. Appel moved back to Washington, and three years later his daughter went to live with him and his new wife. When his mother petitioned for visitation rights, the court ruled that she has no right to court-ordered visits.
It termed the state law unconstitutional because it presumes that visits with a grandparent are in a child's best interest, even if a parent opposes the visits."